Dark Circles: When Does Pico Toning Help?

Dark Circles: When Does Pico Toning Help?

Kim Simon Jang-ju21 min readEditorial policy

Key takeaways

  • Brown, pigment-type dark circles are where pico toning fits. Blue veins and hollow shadows usually call for something else first.
  • Stretch test: if the color stays the same, think pigment. If it gets darker, think blood vessels. If it fades, think loose skin.
  • In a study of 65 people, 78% had a mixed type, so one treatment rarely clears everything.
  • Sessions: in a picosecond laser study, people improved after 3 sessions spaced 3 weeks apart, while a single session in a separate group showed no clear change.

Pico toning makes the most sense when your dark circles are brown and stay the same color when you gently stretch the skin. That pattern points to extra pigment, and pico toning is a laser built to break pigment into smaller pieces. If the darkness looks blue or purple, or it's really a shadow from a hollow under the eye, pigment isn't the main problem, and a different treatment usually comes first.

What Causes Dark Circles Under the Eyes?

What Causes Dark Circles Under the Eyes?What Causes Dark Circles Under the Eyes?

"Dark circles" sounds like one problem, but it's really a few different things that happen to sit in the same spot. The skin under your eyes is some of the thinnest on your face, so whatever is in it or under it shows through easily.

The first cause is pigment. Some people are born with a brown band that follows the curve of the bone under the eye. Others get patchy brown or gray areas after eczema, allergies to eye products, or a lot of rubbing. That second kind is post-inflammatory hyperpigmentation (darkening left behind after irritation).

The second cause is blood vessels. When the skin is thin, the veins and small vessels below it show through as a blue or purple tint.

The third cause is structure. Puffy under-eye fat or a hollow groove along the bone casts a shadow, and the shadow reads as a dark circle even though the skin color itself is normal.

What Causes Dark Circles Under the Eyes?What Causes Dark Circles Under the Eyes?

How Can You Tell Which Type You Have?

How Can You Tell Which Type You Have?How Can You Tell Which Type You Have?

Stand by a bright window with a mirror and try three quick checks. Doctors use the same stretch test, along with a special light, to sort dark circles at a visit.

CheckWhat you noticeLikely typeWhat people usually look at first
Gently stretch the under-eye skin sidewaysThe color stays the samePigmentPigment lasers such as pico toning
Gently stretch the under-eye skin sidewaysBlue veins look even clearerVascularVessel-targeting lasers, checking skin thickness
Gently stretch the under-eye skin sidewaysThe darkness fadesLoose skinOptions that address skin laxity
Shine light straight at your faceThe darkness disappearsShadow (hollow or puffy fat)Options that restore volume

Color helps, too. A brown band that curves along the bone is usually the inborn pigment type. Blotchy brown or gray patches on skin that was once itchy or rough lean toward pigment left by inflammation. If that's you, calming the itch matters, or the color tends to come back.

Why Is Pico Toning the First Option for Brown Dark Circles?

Why Is Pico Toning the First Option for Brown Dark Circles?Why Is Pico Toning the First Option for Brown Dark Circles?

Pigment-type dark circles have extra melanin (skin pigment) packed into the under-eye skin. Pico toning fires low-energy pulses over a wide area in extremely short bursts. Those bursts shatter pigment into tiny pieces, and your body clears them away gradually.

That's also why toning is done as a series. The energy is kept low on purpose so the pigment breaks down a little at a time. Under-eye skin is thin, and pushing hard in a single session can leave brown marks behind once the irritation settles, so I split the work across several visits.

It's worth keeping expectations realistic. In a study of 10 adults who had 3 picosecond laser sessions spaced 3 weeks apart, the under-eye color was still lighter at the last check on day 132. In a separate group of 19 people treated once with different wavelengths, there was no clear improvement at day 60. Both groups were small, and the laser used a fractional lens that delivers dots of energy, which is a bit different from wide-beam toning. Individual results vary.

Laser or Fillers for Dark Circles: Which Fits Your Type?

Laser or Fillers for Dark Circles: Which Fits Your Type?Laser or Fillers for Dark Circles: Which Fits Your Type?

This is one of the most common questions, and the honest answer is that it depends on what's causing the darkness. A review of 39 studies sorted the options like this. Fillers and fat grafting worked best for dark circles caused by lost volume. Eyelid surgery fit best when loose, excess skin was the cause. Lasers gave mild to moderate help for both the vascular and the pigment types.

So if light makes your dark circles vanish, you're looking at a shadow, and toning won't change the shape that casts it. If the color stays put no matter how the light falls, pigment or vessels are more likely, and a laser is the better place to start.

Laser or Fillers for Dark Circles: Which Fits Your Type?Laser or Fillers for Dark Circles: Which Fits Your Type?

Most people don't have just one type. When 65 people were sorted with a special light and ultrasound, 78% had a mix of causes. That's why the pigment can lighten while a shadow still makes the area look dark. In that case, the bigger cause gets treated first.

Can an Eye Cream Fix Dark Circles?

Can an Eye Cream Fix Dark Circles?Can an Eye Cream Fix Dark Circles?

An eye cream is most useful for the pigment type. Brightening creams and chemical peels have a role for pigment-based dark circles. A cream won't fill a hollow or hide a vein, though, so it can't change a shadow or a blue tint.

Ingredients studied for under-eye pigment include hydroquinone, kojic acid, azelaic acid, and retinoic acid. Most of them were tested in melasma first, so the evidence for the under-eye area specifically is thin. When you try a new product near your eyes, start on a small patch before using it everywhere.

Habits often matter more than the jar. Among 200 people with dark circles, 32.5% rubbed their eyes often. Rubbing, scratching, eczema around the eyes, and allergies to cosmetics can all leave more pigment behind. If itching is what makes you rub, deal with the itch first.

Is Laser Treatment Under the Eyes Safe?

Eye protection comes first, every time. In a review of 21 eye injuries from facial lasers, more than 62% happened when eye protection wasn't used or was taken off during treatment. Protective shields should stay on for the entire session.

Redness, swelling, and a stinging feeling can follow a picosecond laser session. Contact your provider right away rather than waiting for the next visit if you notice any of these:

  • Blisters, oozing, or crusting
  • Treated skin turning darker brown
  • Treated skin turning white
  • Eye pain or blurry vision (seek care right away)

Darker skin tones are more prone to darkening after laser treatment. In a study of 12 women whose under-eye areas were treated with a different short-wavelength laser, more of them ended up with extra pigment than with lighter skin. That's why the energy is set while watching how your skin responds.

Planning Around Your Seoul Trip

Unless you've had IV sedation that day, there's no reason to delay a flight after pico toning.

One visit isn't the finish line. Toning works over a series, and a single session didn't show a clear change in the study above, so think of a short trip as a starting point rather than the whole plan.

Once you're home, you can send the clinic photos taken by the same window at the same angle. If you notice eye pain, blurry vision, or blistering, see a local doctor first rather than waiting for a reply.

When Should You Judge the Results?

The one thing to track is whether the color changes when you stretch the skin. Take two photos by a window before you start: one looking straight ahead, and one with the under-eye skin gently stretched. After you finish a series, take the same two photos again. If the brown is lighter but the area still looks dark straight on, a shadow may be the remaining cause. STON Clinic is in Myeongdong, on the 9th floor of Lotte Hotel Seoul's Main Tower near Euljiro 1-ga Station, and you can send that pair of photos ahead of your visit.

Quick booking

References

  1. 65 people with dark circles sorted into pigment, vascular, structural, and mixed types — Int J Dermatol, 2014 — PubMed Central
  2. Causes of dark circles in 200 people, the stretch test, and daily habits — Indian J Dermatol, 2014 — PubMed Central
  3. A review of 39 studies on dark circle treatments — Dermatol Surg, 2021 — PubMed Central
  4. Two picosecond laser studies for under-eye dark circles — Lasers Surg Med, 2018 — PubMed Central
  5. Short-wavelength laser in 12 women with pigment-type dark circles — Lasers Med Sci, 2024 — PubMed Central
  6. 21 eye injuries from cosmetic facial lasers — J Clin Aesthet Dermatol, 2018 — PubMed Central
  7. What picosecond lasers treat and their side effects — DermNet NZ — DermNet NZ
  8. Causes of dark circles and brightening ingredients — J Clin Aesthet Dermatol, 2016 — PubMed Central

Frequently asked questions

Q. Can pico toning lighten dark circles I was born with?

A. It can be an option, since inborn brown dark circles are a pigment problem. In a study of 200 people, though, a special light showed that 60.5% had pigment sitting in the deeper layer of skin. Depth and mixed causes change how the skin responds, so progress is judged with photos after several sessions.

Q. Do dark circles get worse when I don't sleep enough?

A. Lack of sleep showed up in 40% of 200 people with dark circles. Still, sleeping more won't remove pigment that has built up in the skin. If your dark circles are the pigment type, they need a pigment-focused approach on top of better sleep.

Q. Is pico toning riskier for darker skin?

A. Yes, darker skin is more prone to side effects such as extra pigmentation after picosecond laser treatment. For that reason, the energy is usually kept low at first, and the next session is planned after seeing how the skin reacts.

Q. How many pico toning sessions do dark circles need?

A. There's no fixed number. In one small study, improvement showed up after 3 sessions spaced 3 weeks apart, while a single session in another group didn't make a clear difference. Your number depends on the pigment depth and whether other causes are mixed in.

Q. What's the difference between laser and fillers for dark circles?

A. They treat different causes. Lasers target pigment or visible vessels in the skin, while fillers add volume to a hollow that casts a shadow. If light makes the darkness disappear, volume is the bigger issue. If the brown stays when you stretch the skin, pigment is.

Q. Do the results of pico toning last?

A. There isn't enough evidence to say the results last indefinitely. The 3-session study only followed people to day 132. If eye rubbing or eczema around the eyes comes back, pigment can build up again, so cutting down on those triggers matters too.

Q. Can men use the same stretch test?

A. Yes. The stretch test and the light check work the same way for anyone, and the 65-person study included 8 men. It's worth checking whether you rub your eyes often, since that habit can add pigment over time.

Treatment guide for this topic

Kim Simon Jang-ju

Kim Simon Jang-ju Head Physician

JANGJU KIM

Head Physician Kim Simon Jang-ju practices at STON Clinic, LOTTE HOTEL in Myeongdong (from December 1, 2026).

Career / Education

  • Current) Head Physician (practicing at STON Clinic Myeongdong and Beautystone Clinic Hapjeong; Myeongdong from Dec 1, 2026)
  • Graduated from Kyung Hee University College of Medicine
View profile

Comments